Fish is just great!! Expect a wait out the door during busy time, but it’s well worth it!! Fresh fresh fresh local catches, can’t beat it!!
Very delicious options. Several different fish each cooked several different ways, with several different sides!!! So many combinations, and that's just the "Fresh Catch Plates". In addition to that they have fish burgers, tacos, and a decent kids menu. They have their own very tasty and delicious"Magic Sauce," the Cajun Style Oho, with potatoes and Cajun style rice, was just super delicious.
Alex Le
-
March 10, 2024
Quaint little place serving delicious fresh caught fish. We came in after the Road to Hana like many others on a late afternoon and luckily had a short wait. The deep fried calamari was so hot and fresh and flavorful, and the cajun Ono and sauteed Mahi Mahi were so buttery and fresh. For the price I felt the portions were plentiful and the sides to each dish were also good. Great service and atmosphere.
Pamela Corona
-
April 25, 2024
The shrimp cocktail was pretty basic which is why I’m not giving them 5 stars. I got 6 cooked shrimp with cocktail sauce on the side (I know that’s the American shrimp cocktail but… why stick to that?). The fish tacos were very pretty good and paired well with their home magic sauce. We enjoyed the ahi sashimi, nothing amazing, just fresh and good quality. It did feel a little crowded, we went on a Wednesday around 2pm. It’s a make a line, pay your order and find a seat kind of place. They do have very fresh fish, just wish they were more creative with their preparations.
Jay Weaver
-
January 15, 2024
This is a small place, there was a long line with a 20 minute wait when we arrived. This was recommended by a friend. I got the fish and chips, it came with 3 small pieces that were fried to much for my taste. The slaw was good.
My wife got the fish quesadilla, it was delicious much better than the fish I had. It was very loud and small. Just be aware then you will be fine.
Parking is an issue, park in the free lot by the shell station. As road side is difficult to find an open place.
Arthur Molines
-
February 22, 2024
We had a quick dinner.
The place was packed with locals and visitors.
The food was good. The fries were tasty.
The grilled Ono was cooked and seasoned well it was very nice in the burger.
Our Address
100 Baldwin Ave, Paia, HI 96779, USA
Claim Listing: Paia Fish Market
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Fish is just great!! Expect a wait out the door during busy time, but it’s well worth it!! Fresh fresh fresh local catches, can’t beat it!! Very delicious options. Several different fish each cooked several different ways, with several different sides!!! So many combinations, and that's just the "Fresh Catch Plates". In addition to that they have fish burgers, tacos, and a decent kids menu. They have their own very tasty and delicious"Magic Sauce," the Cajun Style Oho, with potatoes and Cajun style rice, was just super delicious.
Quaint little place serving delicious fresh caught fish. We came in after the Road to Hana like many others on a late afternoon and luckily had a short wait. The deep fried calamari was so hot and fresh and flavorful, and the cajun Ono and sauteed Mahi Mahi were so buttery and fresh. For the price I felt the portions were plentiful and the sides to each dish were also good. Great service and atmosphere.
The shrimp cocktail was pretty basic which is why I’m not giving them 5 stars. I got 6 cooked shrimp with cocktail sauce on the side (I know that’s the American shrimp cocktail but… why stick to that?). The fish tacos were very pretty good and paired well with their home magic sauce. We enjoyed the ahi sashimi, nothing amazing, just fresh and good quality. It did feel a little crowded, we went on a Wednesday around 2pm. It’s a make a line, pay your order and find a seat kind of place. They do have very fresh fish, just wish they were more creative with their preparations.
This is a small place, there was a long line with a 20 minute wait when we arrived. This was recommended by a friend. I got the fish and chips, it came with 3 small pieces that were fried to much for my taste. The slaw was good. My wife got the fish quesadilla, it was delicious much better than the fish I had. It was very loud and small. Just be aware then you will be fine. Parking is an issue, park in the free lot by the shell station. As road side is difficult to find an open place.
We had a quick dinner. The place was packed with locals and visitors. The food was good. The fries were tasty. The grilled Ono was cooked and seasoned well it was very nice in the burger.