Good:
1) Blackened mahi mahi was delicious. Per other reviews I suspect this might be the best thing they do. Really great.
2) Good prices. Easy to get a seat despite the line.
Bad:
1) Ono is supposed to be the least fishy fish on their menu but the Ono burger was very fishy which would imply overcooked or not fresh/stored right. Other reviews seems to agree.
2) Somewhat rude waitstaff. One stood behind a group whilst holding plates saying ‘behind, behind’. Could’ve just said excuse me. She also looked miserable the whole time.
Nhi Nguyen
-
March 08, 2025
The food here was delicious and well-seasoned! We got the fish tacos, blackened snapper plate, and calamari. The portion sizes were huge, and we had a ton of leftovers. There was a line when we went for dinner, but it moved pretty quickly. They sat multiple parties together at the same table to maximize seating.
Arya Phatak
-
April 29, 2025
Had been here for the first time. There was a line to get in and order but it was quick. We ordered clam chowder, seafood pasta and mahi mahi fish plate with Cajun rice and Cajun seasoning. The food arrived pretty quickly. The chowder was hot and wholesome . The highlight was the seafood pasta. Extremely delicious and creamy with tender fish and shrimp. Would highly recommend. I will be dreaming about it for months. The fish and Cajun rice was also bomb. Loved how perfectly the fish was cooked. Nice flavors. Service was friendly and quick.
Mason King
-
January 21, 2025
Great spot to eat. The prices are great compared to most other restaurants on the island but you still get tons of food and it's quite good. The fish tacos were amazing and the snapper was so good. The calamari was good too and only $9. Hard to beat that. I recommend this spot a lot of you are in the area
Megan Ou
-
January 05, 2025
Very casual spot for dining with huge portions and delicious dishes all for a reasonable price. I highly recommend the charbroiled fresh fish with the Cajun rice and the seafood pasta. Onion rings were very hot and crispy. The iced tea was also very refreshing. The servers were super nice and it didn't take long for the food to get to us. If you plan on going during a peak dining hour expect a slight wait in line to order. The seating is slightly limited but it clears out pretty quickly.
Our Address
100 Baldwin Ave, Paia, HI 96779, USA
Claim Listing: Paia Fish Market
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Good: 1) Blackened mahi mahi was delicious. Per other reviews I suspect this might be the best thing they do. Really great. 2) Good prices. Easy to get a seat despite the line. Bad: 1) Ono is supposed to be the least fishy fish on their menu but the Ono burger was very fishy which would imply overcooked or not fresh/stored right. Other reviews seems to agree. 2) Somewhat rude waitstaff. One stood behind a group whilst holding plates saying ‘behind, behind’. Could’ve just said excuse me. She also looked miserable the whole time.
The food here was delicious and well-seasoned! We got the fish tacos, blackened snapper plate, and calamari. The portion sizes were huge, and we had a ton of leftovers. There was a line when we went for dinner, but it moved pretty quickly. They sat multiple parties together at the same table to maximize seating.
Had been here for the first time. There was a line to get in and order but it was quick. We ordered clam chowder, seafood pasta and mahi mahi fish plate with Cajun rice and Cajun seasoning. The food arrived pretty quickly. The chowder was hot and wholesome . The highlight was the seafood pasta. Extremely delicious and creamy with tender fish and shrimp. Would highly recommend. I will be dreaming about it for months. The fish and Cajun rice was also bomb. Loved how perfectly the fish was cooked. Nice flavors. Service was friendly and quick.
Great spot to eat. The prices are great compared to most other restaurants on the island but you still get tons of food and it's quite good. The fish tacos were amazing and the snapper was so good. The calamari was good too and only $9. Hard to beat that. I recommend this spot a lot of you are in the area
Very casual spot for dining with huge portions and delicious dishes all for a reasonable price. I highly recommend the charbroiled fresh fish with the Cajun rice and the seafood pasta. Onion rings were very hot and crispy. The iced tea was also very refreshing. The servers were super nice and it didn't take long for the food to get to us. If you plan on going during a peak dining hour expect a slight wait in line to order. The seating is slightly limited but it clears out pretty quickly.