Paia Fish Market

100 Baldwin Ave, Paia, HI 96779, USA

About Paia Fish Market

4.6 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Innovative Constructions
    September 09, 2022

    Ok so we were visiting Maui and had already swam at two different waterfalls and were rally hungry so needed to land a good restaurant to eat. This place has lots of fish dishes so I ordered the salmon with potatoes and salad. It didn’t disappoint. The salmon was nice a soft yet cooked well and the rest on the plate was great too. I also ordered a dark local Maui beer and that too was great. So for sure I recommend going here if you’re visiting or if you’re local as well. Highly recommended.

    Mr. X
    December 05, 2022

    This place was on my radar the last time we went through Paia, but we had to skip it because the line was out the door and onto the street. I should have known there was a reason for that. I ordered the fish and chips, I use it as a metric to test a restaurant, and a Guava Jarritos soda. Never seen that one before so I had to try it. I also got the calamari because I love calamari strips. The cocktail sauce that came with the calamari had a slight, and I mean slight, kick to it, but it was so delicious I almost requested a bath be filled with it. The fish and chips were good, but I'm not a fan of shoestring fries. The slaw that came with my meal was delicious. I don't usually eat slaw, but the tartar sauce made such a difference I ate the majority of it. The homemade tartar sauce was so good. I thought about skipping it, the fish was good without it, but something told me I needed to try it so I did. It was delicious. There was dill, salt, and lemon in it and it made what could have been a very dull tartar very good. Great job!

    Troy Broas
    December 30, 2021

    Great place for fresh fish! The menu also includes other things like burgers, salads and I believe chicken, but be sure to try the fish. We tried the fish and chips and it was fresh with a good portion size. The meal also comes with slaw and a tartar sauce. This is different than traditional fish and chips because it is breaded and not battered, but it’s still very good. This place gets very busy, so be prepared for a potential wait in line, however it is worth it. Good food, very friendly service and staff, a must try if you are visiting Paia.

    Emily palmer
    June 14, 2022

    A nice place to stop for lunch, albeit crowded. The line moves relatively fast though. Our food was great, some of us had large portions though. I got a salad with chicken (pictured) which was good, the chicken was a little salty for me, but not unbearable. My family also got some shrimp dishes, hamburger, and vegetarian quesadilla (pictured) which they though were good. I would definitely recommend, just note there may be a line peak dining times.

    Sufei Zhao
    July 10, 2022

    Such fresh seafood! I highly recommend any of the fresh catch plates (I loved the Cajun snapper with fries). Try it with their paia magic sauce. The fried shrimp appetizer was also amazing. You have to order before being seated, but the service was super quick, from getting your food to them cleaning tables in between guests.

    Paia Fish Market

    Our Address

    100 Baldwin Ave, Paia, HI 96779, USA

    Add Your Business To, It's FREE!

    If you would like to add your business listing to our website please click here or contact us today!